2012 · 4 stars · fantasy · mg · ya

review; saving moby dick

Title: Saving Moby Dick (The Enchanted Attic #2)
Author: L.L. Samson
Pub. Date: September, 2012
Summary: In Saving Moby Dick, Linus, Ophelia, and their friend Walter think they can control the powers of the Enchanted Attic, and they plan to bring Captain Ahab from Book World into Real World-on their own terms. But even the best-laid plans go awry sometimes, and their adventures take a wild turn. Captain Ahab is far crazier than they realized, and bookstores aren’t really the best places to find whales, white or otherwise.
Genre: MG, Fantasy
Rating:

Linus and Ophelia had roped poor Walter into serving hors d’oeuvres with them, believing fully in the old adage that misery loves company. In other words, if you have something you’d rather not do, you might as well bring your best friend along and let him suffer as well.

Guys, this series is growing on me. A lot. I had a few problems with the first book, Facing the Hunchback of Notre Dame, and I’m pleased to say those problems have all but vanished in this sequel. Twins Linus and Ophilia Easterday have been shipped off to live with their aunt and uncle (also twins) while their parents hunt butterflies on a remote island in the South Pacific. Their good friend Walter resides in the nearby boarding school after more than his share of picked locks back home in London.

Aunt Portia owns a bookshop and in its attic the trio discovered an enchanted circle that can bring literary characters into our world. Naturally this comes with some rules: they have sixty hours before they need to return, the circle only opens once a month, etc. In their previous adventure with the circle, they met Quasimodo. This time around they set the bar a bit higher: Moby Dick‘s Captain Ahab.

Meanwhile, Aunt Portia didn’t care about the Moby Dick theme at all. She figured it was a water party and mermaids live in the water, so it stood to reason that she could fudge a little bit.

Every single character is great. They’re funny, they’re flawed, they have their own distinct personality and I love it. I’m also very pleased to say that Walter’s love of exercising isn’t shown to the extent it was in the previous book (during a pretty important scene in the first book, Walter randomly started doing push-ups.

Whereas Quasimodo was sweet and kind, Ahab is anything but. He’s a man on a mission and is blinded by his revenge. He also doesn’t take too kindly to being ordered around by three 14-year olds. That said, his fascination with modern technology (indoor plumbing, computers) is hilarious and I loved the scenes where he’s wrecking havoc on message boards on a whaling website.

We also see more of Cato Grubbs, the mad scientist who previously owned the house/bookshop before suddenly disappearing. In Saving Moby Dick we discover a bit more about him and his relationship to the twins.

The only drawback to this book (and this series as a whole) is the narrator. Bartholomew Inkster works in the English Department of Kingscross University and while I enjoy him 90% of the time, his constant need to define words can be a bit grating. This series is targeted toward the 9-12 crowd. I highly doubt they need words like ingest, clear-cut, or fumble explained.

“Curse that foul tome!” he roared. “I curse the day it was ever written, this Herman Melville reaching down into my soul and displaying it for all the world to see.”

Saving Moby Dick is a wonderful display of what a sequel should be. It’s issues have all been ironed over and since the world-building and magical rules have already been introduced in the first book, the story can finally get down to business. Short chapters and a quick pace make this book a breeze. Also, one of the characters is a bounty-hunter-turned-hippie-priest. How could you pass that up??

The Enchanted Attic Series

  • Facing the Hunchback of Notre Dame (review → here!)
  • Saving Moby Dick
  • Dueling with the Three Musketeers (1/13)
  • Wrestling with Tom Sawyer (5/13)
Advertisements

2 thoughts on “review; saving moby dick

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s